Extra thought on Paradise Lost

Paradise Lost is my favorite and most-read epic poem. Every time I read it, I start feeling compassionate for everything– irrationally involved with people and the world. I share Milton’s underlying sentiments, and also find myself siding with Satan throughout the epic. The ‘villain’ is always more interesting and complex than the hero, after all. After finishing the poem, I can’t help but wonder why all of these people who believe in God don’t pray for Satan: the biggest sinner, the fallen angel, the most scorned, the one who needs a prayer the most. Centuries upon centuries and I wonder if anyone has thought of him with a heavy, forgiving heart.

Paradise Lost: The Temptation of Adam and Eve

Paradise Lost by John Milton is centered in a perfect existence: the Garden of Eden and its two inhabitants, Adam and Eve. The foundation of the story is creation and then the demise, or the Fall of humankind. Milton’s epic retelling of these events focuses on how Satan, Adam and Eve’s actions contribute and lead up to the Fall. The course Satan pursues to lead the couple into temptation is well observed and planned out, which explains the reason he approaches Eve rather than Adam. He is able to tempt Eve with intellectual language, flattery, and the promise of things she has subconsciously sought since she awoke into her new existence. In return, Adam is tempted not by Satan to disobey God, but by his own wife Eve. Milton is successful in creating the reader to feel sympathy for each character at different times, which causes complexity when deciphering who is ultimately to blame: Adam or Eve? In Paradise Lose, Adam and Eve are tempted to eat the fruit from The Tree of Knowledge by different methods, and by default are both to blame for the Fall.

Eve, from the time she comes to be in Paradise, questions her existence. Her first thoughts upon waking are “wondering where and what I was, whence thither brought, and how” (IV.451-452). She shares these thoughts and her findings of the path leading to the river reflecting her own face. During this interaction, Satan observes the adamant and obedient Adam, but also the curious and knowledge-seeking Eve. He learns God has given them one rule not to break: to not eat the forbidden fruit from the Tree of Knowledge. In consideration of her search for identity, independency, and knowledge— Eve appears to be the obvious target for Satan to carry out his plan of the couple succumbing to temptation, therefor exacting revenge on God.

In Book IX, Eve exudes her search for independence by suggesting to Adam that they work separately for the day to complete the large workload ahead of them. Although hesitant, he obliges, and this is where Satan elatedly finds Eve on her lonesome to confront her. He is very clever with his methods of communication before hurtling straight into persuading Eve into eating the fruit. He entices her with flattery by complimenting her beauty, elegance, and basically worshiping her for these vanities in a god-like manner. Satan is aware his flattery is highly effective since Eve was earlier enamored with her own reflection. Next, he attacks another one of her weaknesses: the desire for knowledge. Eve is amazed at the swiftness of Satan’s, or technically the serpent’s, tongue since she has never experienced someone in the Garden speak with such intellect. The curiosity and flattery Satan provokes out of Eve leads her to follow him to what then she realizes is the tree that holds the forbidden fruit.

As Eve is persuaded, and ultimately eats the forbidden fruit, it is easy to view her as selfish, narcissistic, or even a villain with the likes of Satan. In reality, she is an individual with a very limited knowledge of the world she was brought into and a bursting curiosity of what the place is and who she is. Her intent when eating the fruit, although disobedient, is not with malicious intent. She is naïve and innocent, with a burning desire to feed her hunger for independency, knowledge and power. She does not understand that these are the factors of which will bring the Fall of humankind. At this point in her story, she cannot genuinely grasp what true evil or even death is, which she exemplifies by saying she does not believe her or Adam are “capable of death or pain” (IX.283). Satan only further “proves” how Eve feels and that God’s warnings must be false since he, the serpent, is still alive and speaking eloquently. In conclusion to his temptation of Eve to eat the Forbidden fruit, he utilizes his arguments to support himself and dispute God, and in the end Eve is not equipped to fight this on the same intellectual level as Satan.

While Eve’s weaknesses pertain to knowledge and independency—Adam’s weakness is beauty and Eve, herself. Satan does not have to tempt Adam firsthand, but rather uses Eve as a vessel to do so. After eating the fruit, and overindulging in it, the first thing she does is run to Adam and gives him a retelling of the day’s events. At first panicked and disappointed at the news, he ultimately comes to the conclusion that he does not want to be without Eve. Throughout Paradise Lost, Adam’s character seemingly lacks an identity and it makes sense that he would look to a stronger character, like Eve, to guide his decision-making. Eve’s jealousy of him finding a replacement for her, along with Adam’s inability to go on living without Eve, is responsible for his temptation and ending decision to eat the Forbidden fruit, even though he understands this means they are now doomed.

The difference in the pair’s sinning is that Eve craves knowledge and eats the fruit by choice, whereas Adam does so because he feels he has no other option. It is hard to play the blame game when there are three such prominent characters playing a part: Satan, Adam, and Eve. Obviously, Satan is at fault for setting the entire Fall of humankind into action, and it would be easy to place all of the blame on his first target, Eve. The facts are all there: she is tempted and sins first, and then goes on to bring Adam down with her. But when he is asked if he tasted the fruit from the Tree of Knowledge, Adam is unsure whether or not to take responsibility or to place the blame solely on Eve. He settles on something in between and replies that Eve “gave me of the tree, and I did eat” (IX.174). I think to say that both Adam and Eve are to blame is the fairest response due to one important concept: free will.

Simply put, Satan has malicious intent, Eve sins first, and Adam follows in her footsteps for her. The downfall is a domino effect, a waterfall that trickled down into what was to be the Fall of humankind. The truth of the blame game is that every one possesses free will and makes their decisions. Satan is the true one to blame, and we see that his punishment is greater than that of Adam and Eve. In conclusion, Adam and Eve are tempted to sin in different ways but neither necessarily holds more blame than the other since they both have God’s gift of free will.

 

 

Work Cited

Lawall, Sarah N. The Norton Anthology of Western Literature. New York: W.W. Norton, 2006. Print.

Human Honor Vs Human Frailty

English literature up until the 1700s has a number of reoccurring themes, ones that particularly pertain to the subject’s personal integrity and heroic code. The idea of ‘human honor’ is essential and often highlighted in this period of literature. In the heroic society of each piece, the reader is exposed to an emphasis put on the heroes’ ultimate desires of fame, honor, and a world-renowned reputation, as a result of their battles or tasks. They would rather die than act with cowardice, lack of honor, or failure in the task at hand. I found with this all-or-nothing attitude, the hero’s die-hard ambition allows them either to succeed in perceivably impossible tasks or spiral down into a failure that exposes the undeniable frailty of the human race. I will explore these ideas further in heroic poems, following with Beowulf, and concluding with “Sir Gawain and the Green Knight.” In this literature, the concept of ‘Human Honor vs Human Frailty’ have best and worst scenarios for both sides, but most importantly can still relate to the modern reader in regards to their own life and human nature as a whole.

The best and worst of human honor and frailty can be seen in both the heroic poems “The Battle of Maldon” and Beowulf. Each of the narratives addresses cowardice and brevity seen in the poem’s characters. In “The Battle of Maldon,” Byrhthnoth’s death is a symbol of human honor in various ways. His very death and dying words were redeemed heroic and are “rightly regarded as the supreme statement of the Germanic heroic code” (5). Beowulf places himself in the path of danger more than the reader can believe, all for the name of fame, glory, and being renowned around the world. As they fight to obtain this, the men who remain loyal to them choose to self-sacrifice in order to support and fight alongside their leader. This showed valor, loyalty, and courage: the ultimate desires of a warrior of this time. On the other hand, there were a few of the warriors who showed a less than favorable side of human nature: cowardice, foolishness, or worst of all— hubris.

I found it very easy to look at the actions of Beowulf, or other characters in these stories, and feel a swelling admiration for the strength it must take to become incredibly sacrificial. Then, I had a moment of clarity: is the obsession with how one is remembered after death the ultimate human frailty? The constant quest for glory turned into martyrdom by the end of Beowulf’s life. I see human honor in the comrades who valiantly fight by their friends and leaders, but I do see flaw in the human character when someone takes on a fight they know they will lose with the sole purpose of protecting their pride.

In “Sir Gawain and the Green Knight,” the main character was very different than of those in the heroic poems and Beowulf. Gawain was a believable character in the fact that he was not perfect, and quite frankly that is what being human is all about. Throughout this poem, Gawain is held in high esteem due to where he comes from. He does indeed act with brevity, honor, and loyalty— that is until the pressure of his life ending looms near. In the hopes of preserving his own life, he lies about the belt given to him by the more beautiful of the two ladies. Gawain omits his gift of the magical belt when the lord returns home and this exposes his human nature. The human frailty, or weakness in this, is the goal to keep a person’s life alive. I believe this is why, even though they made a promise such as Gawain did, there were warriors who flew the scene in Beowulf once they saw their life was fully at stake.

In conclusion, the comparison of human honor and human frailty are both heavily prevalent in the heroic poems, Beowulf, and Sir Gawain and the Green Knight. The best- case scenarios include, for instance, Beowulf self-sacrificing himself to kill Grendel and give people the chance to live in peace. But it became less valiant as he became older and was no longer fit to fight the same battles, which let his pride fuel his decision to undergo his last battle. In each character, there is a point when human frailty rears its face and instead of becoming a martyr for a populations sake, it is for their own pride and desire for glory. A character that craves fame, glory, and recognition over anything, to the point they will die for it: that could be an indicator of the worst in human honor and frailty.

As a reader, I found myself identifying closest with Sir Gawain due to how perfectly imperfect he was. In the process of wanting to save his own life, he lied and went against honor by keeping the belt to himself. Although, like many other emotions humans have— he felt shame and exerted honesty. He even went home and exclaimed his faults to his people, prepared to live with the downfall of his actions. I think the course of actions taken by Gawain in this poem are the most relatable to the modern reader due to the fact that we often know what is the right thing to do, but fear often keeps us from doing that very thing if it means preserving ourselves. It’s the horrible flaw of being human: the desire to live a memorable, dignified, loyal life without being consumed by hubris or stepping on toes to survive.

Work Cited

Crossley-Holland, Kevin. The Anglo-Saxon World: An Anthology. Oxford: Oxford UP, 1999. Print.

Black Feminism and the Jezebel Stereotype

Throughout time, and continuing in modern society, the portrayal of the Black woman has endured multiple stereotypes, but one especially prurient by nature: the Jezebel. The term originates from the queen Jezebel of the Bible who is highly sexual and uses it as manipulation to obtain things she wants, which varies from material and emotional desires. The stereotype has influenced different groups of people to often view African-American females with an immoral and promiscuous perspective.

The stereotype characterizes Black women as hypersexual and has noticeably appeared in media, especially with influences in advertisement and film. It has served as an oppression to the Black woman and problematic in her formation of self-perception and identity. I will present and analyze cultural artifacts that support how the goals, concepts and philosophies of Black feminism were created as a response to them and also exist as a solution.

The creation of the ideas, goals and philosophy of Black feminism were and continue to be necessary in order to confront and seek resolution to issues, including stereotyping. Black feminism is defined by sociologist Patricia Hill Collins as “a process of self-conscious struggle that empowers women and men to actualize a humanist vision of community” (Collins). A sense of empowerment should be present within the individual, the community, and society since issues stem from each of the areas. In their own communities, unavoidable adversities have existed in poor educational and professional conditions, poverty, and emotional or physical abuse in their relationships.

As established in many discussions and readings, what sets Black feminism apart from general feminism itself is the double-jeopardy African-American women face regarding oppression from their race and gender. With each cultural movement our society has experienced, a definite position for the Black woman has ostensibly lacked. The progress other men and women have achieved does not match that of African-American women. Our class handout “The Black Feminist Standpoint: Questions and Answers” explains how the Civil Rights Movement advantaged men, including African-American males, and the favoritism second-wave feminism held in focus of middle-class white women.

Several stereotypes of the African-American woman have stubbornly remained intact before, during, and after the Civil Rights Movement. Although women as a whole have shared common oppressions, many had the fortune of escaping the same stereotyping Black women have experienced, specifically the Jezebel stereotype. The stereotypes in concern of a woman’s appearance and sexuality have maintained to be exceedingly different for a Caucasian and African-American woman. Throughout history, a white woman has often been associated or viewed with the perspectives of modesty and purity. On the contrary, the Jezebel stereotype of the Black woman has associated them with adjectives of an erotic, promiscuous, and lewd nature.

In an exploration and analysis of cultural artifacts, the Jezebel stereotype proved to run rampant in media such as advertisements and films. The categorization can occur to any Black woman, but there was a noticeable pattern within the stereotype and the artifacts. The African-American models and actresses in the examples formed a pattern that supported the stereotype and exhibited exploitation to help sell a product or promote an image. The women possessed lighter skin tones, narrower features, and slender bodies. It is an occurrence that can be seen in not only society and media of the past, but also in our modern world.

For example, my first artifact: a 1960 advertisement for Kent cigarettes, in celebration of their 200-year anniversary. The advertisement presents an African-American woman posing seductively with a cigarette. She possesses a light skin tone along with finer, Anglo-Saxon features. The slogan surrounding her reads, “Kent Satisfies Your Appetite For a Real Good Smoke” (Fig.1). The choice of model, her pose, and the included slogan all pose their own issues.
The choiearly_16ce of using an African-American model with light skin provokes an emphasis on the stigma that was historically placed on skin-tone in Black women. It was a reoccurring theme in several of the readings and discussions in our class. The idea can be traced back to our initial reading of Zora Neale Hurston’s life and work. In the introduction of I Love Myself When I Am Laughing, there are several depictions of her appearance recollected from a spectrum of friends, colleagues, and critics.

Mary Helen Washington comments on the contradicting and vast descriptions by stating, “Whether Zora Neale Hurston was black as coal, light yellow, or light brown seems to have depended a great deal on the imagination and mind-set of the observer” (Washington 1). Their responses prove that a Black woman’s character is often associated with her skin color, even if committed subconsciously. The people that thought of her fondly described her at the lightest color, and the bitterest comments stated the darkest.

Another example can be found in Hurston’s novel Their Eyes Were Watching God. The protagonist, Janie Mae Crawford, is noted and admired most throughout the novel for her long, beautiful hair that was a result of her mixed ancestry. Janie’s Caucasian features are what landed her the affection and friendship of Mrs. Turner. She placed indicators of worth and respect of an African-American woman that depend of how “white” they appeared. Mrs. Turner’s pride in her own Caucasian-like features and spite for anyone with an appearance of strong African-American descent, exudes a sense of internalized racism.

The choice of model in the Kent advertisement, like in countless other ads, attempts to form a singular perspective of what beauty is in the African-American woman. This is detrimental to the Black woman herself, since it can create a sense of self-consciousness and struggle with identity. The character of Mrs. Turner and her internalized racism are a prime example of how stereotyping can cause a negative effect. In the modern world, the use of racially diverse models has improved, but there is still an apparent stigma that is placed on having lighter skin, even when the individual is of African-American ethnicity.

To continue, the model’s pose in the advertisement is manipulated into open body language, an alluring facial expression, and the seductiveness of a lit cigarette in her hand. Even further, the slogan to sell the product includes the phrase “satisfies your appetite,” which aligns with the Jezabel stereotype. Even though the advertisers were referring to the product they wanted to sell, they were using the model as a large part to do so. She was used as a symbol and viewed by an audience as a woman with a suggestive and promiscuous desire to satisfy sexual desires.

Although there are negative connotations attached, the image can be something African-American women willingly comply to at times. In Sister Citizen: Shame, Stereotypes, and Black Women in America by Melissa V. Harris Perry, the confusing situation Black women can find themselves in when they confront race and gender stereotypes. Perry states, “Bombarded with warped images of their humanity, some black women tilt and bend themselves to fit the distortion. It may be surprising that some gyrate half-naked in degrading hip-hop videos that reinforce the image of black women’s lewdness” (Perry 29). Stereotyping can pose the slippery slope of encouraging a woman to feel the need to negotiate her identity. By altering herself, or conforming to a stereotype, the Black woman might feel it is necessary to succeed or to be visible in society.

That brings me to my second artifact: the 1974 film Foxy Brown, starring Pam Grier. It is an example of how the Jezebel stereotype was infamously used to categorize black women in Hollywood movies. Similar to the advertisements, the stereotype presents a woman in film that is to be viewed as promiscuous and hypersexual. The characters are often meant to take on the image of a ‘bad girl’ who possesses a large attitude and the ability to take care of herself.
foxybrownposterFoxy Brown was a sexually aggressive, seemingly independent woman with a tougher than nails attitude and persona. On the movie poster, her character is posed in a revealing dress and a caption reads, “Don’t mess with…Foxy Brown, she’s the meanest chick in town” (fig. 2). While the existence of a strong black female is not necessarily a negative idea to present in film, its previous and ongoing execution and heavy utilization to justify negative relationships and scenes raise a red flag.

Unfortunately, the stereotype was used to justify negative sexual relationships between black women and white men in many early films that included cases of abuse and rape. In the past, primarily before the 1960s, the stereotype had such a strong influence on people’s minds that often if an African-American woman reported rape by a white man, no justice would come of it. This is just another example of how stereotypes, like the Jezebel, have had a long-lasting impact on Black women psychologically, socially, in relationships, and in their community.

With much of this said, it does not mean there is anything wrong with the model we see in the Kent cigarette advertisement, or the celebrities in modern society, such as Rihanna or Beyoncé, with features akin to Hurston’s Janie Mae Crawford. Even more important, Black women should not feel the need to alter their dress, actions, or sexuality simply because they are afraid of being a stereotype.

Through understanding and applying the concepts of Black feminism, there are ways to navigate the confusing world of stereotypes and to ultimately make a difference. There have already been substantial accomplishments made by women who identify as Black feminists and communicate through diverse outlets such as politics, literature, art, music, and more.

Melissa V. Harris Perry summarizes this notion exceptionally well in the first chapter, “Crowded Room,” of Sister Citizen. Perry refers to navigating stereotypes successfully by stating, “Hurston’s account of Janie Mae Crawford in Their Eyes Were Watching God is a literary example of the ability to find the upright” and continues to say, “Black women of the early twentieth-century club movement resisted the lie of black promiscuity by leading a movement for temperance, modesty, and respectability” (Perry 31). Before, during and after the Civil Rights Movement women have fought peacefully for their own movement and visibility in society without having to compromise themselves or fall victim to stereotyping.

The cultural artifact examples I have provided possessed negative elements of stereotyping, specifically of the Jezebel stereotype. The philosophy and concepts of black feminism serve as an efficient response to the oppression, prejudice and stereotyping seen in many cultural artifacts prior, during and after the Civil Rights Movement. In modern society, the concepts that Black feminism have to offer can continue to act as a solution to the stereotypes, including Jezabel.

The beautiful part about Black feminism being a solution to stereotyping is that it is accessible to every one. Men and women of any race, age, or other factor can be considered a Black feminist. But Patricia Hill Collins summarizes the idea of who is one, generally, by stating “The full actualization of Black feminist thought requires a collaborative enterprise with Black women at the center of a community based on coalitions among autonomous groups” (Collins).

By using the ideas, perspectives, and experiences of Black women as a central focus, both men and women of all color can work towards empowering each other and people of their communities. The goal is not to have Black females reach a higher stance in society than other races or gender, but to reach a point of equality that is idealistic for every group to exist together. The abolishment of stereotyping is necessary to avoid the issues it can create for the African-American women in their inner-perceptions, communities, relationships, and connection to the rest of society.

 

 

Work Cited

Collins, Patricia Hill. Black Feminist Thought: Knowledge, Consciousness, and the Politics of Empowerment. New York: Routledge, 2000. Print.

Harris-Perry, Melissa V. Sister Citizen: Shame, Stereotypes, and Black Women in America. New Haven: Yale UP, 2011. Print.

Hurston, Zora Neale., and Alice Walker. I Love Myself When I Am Laughing … and Then Again When I Am Looking Mean and Impressive: A Zora Neale Hurston Reader. Old Westbury, NY: Feminist, 1979. Print.

Figure 1. “Early Black Ads.” Stanford. N.p., n.d. Web. 06 May 2015. .

Figure 2. “Foxy Brown and Aunt Jemima, Exposed.” The Lazy Scholar. N.p., 09 Dec. 2009. Web. 06 May 2015.

Black Feminism: Hurston and Bambara

In the essays, “How It Feels to Be Colored Me” by Zora Neale Hurston and “On the Issue of Roles” by Toni Cade Bambara, both authors exhibit Black feministic themes in their writing. These themes include the intersectionalism of being black and a female, and what it means to observe these characteristics together instead of as separate entities. Both Hurston and Bambara serve as Black feminist writers because they theorize and discuss their experiences of being ordinary black women in a world full of discrimination, and what it means to create a revolution within one’s self and society. Although they were born nearly fifty years apart, the two women share many of the same thoughts and themes of Black feminism in their writing. In both of the essays, Hurston and Bambara can identify with being an African-American female growing up in America, but with some cultural differences due to what the societal position in race and gender discrimination was at the time of publication.

“How It Feels to Be Colored Me” is an autobiographical essay by Hurston that depicts “the very day [she] became colored” (151). She grew up and flourished as a writer during a time in history with a ferocious sense of racism and oppression. Although, she escaped certain social consequences from Jim Crow Laws since she lived in Eatonville, a town with an all African-American residency. In this essay, and many of her other works, she describes being a colored woman in America, and her journey of self-realization. An interesting characteristic of her work and what makes her a prototype for Black feminism, is her ability to remove herself from the stigma and significance placed on skin color, yet to self-revolutionize as a black woman. As a child, Hurston identifies as just Zora, the person she sees herself as. Later, as she becomes aware of her color in society she states, “I was not Zora of Orange County any more, I was now a little colored girl” (152).

Undoubtedly, Hurston begins to feel the weight of living in a world where being different is hard, and being colored is exasperating. Nonetheless, she determinedly makes a point, which distinguishes her from belonging to any victimized stereotype, by stating, “But I am not tragically colored. There is no great sorrow dammed up in my soul, nor lurking behind my eyes” (152). This exhibits her pride and courage in not only herself, but also the African-American community of her time. Instead of putting further significance on the differences of skin color or becoming cemented in the negativity inflicted upon her race, she chooses to celebrate herself and her community for exactly what they are: unique and interesting individuals who live in America. It is important to note that she is not blind to discrimination, but rather chooses to absorb it and reflect on it in her own way. Sometimes she speaks of feeling her race in a positive light, a daunting way, and then other times completely neutral. Hurston displays her self-autonomy by stating, “At certain times I have no race, I am me” (153). This summarizes her ability to observe and analyze the struggle of being an African-American woman, yet identifying as an individual that is equal to any other person in society. To me, that is a central attribute that makes her a prototype of Black feminism and a model for future writers, such as Bambara.

In “On the Issue of Roles,” an excerpt from the autobiographical essay, The Scattered Sopranos, by Toni Cade Bambara, the author confronts a topic frequently brought up to her: the Black Woman’s Role in the Revolution. Unlike Hurston’s essay, Bambara focuses more on the gender aspect of the intersectionalism that creates Black feminism. Hurston’s writing develops in a historical period focused in the civil rights movement, whereas Bambara’s writing is centralized in a time that focuses on the ongoing argument and revolution of gender roles and equality. Bambara has many opinions and perspectives that stem from Hurston, including her neutrality towards gender and a theme of self-realization and self-revolution. As she addresses “masculine” and “feminine” stereotypes in gender roles, Bambara explains, “I always found the either/or implicit in those definitions antithetical to what I was all about—and for what revolution of self is all about—the whole person” (123). This is a prime example of what makes her, akin to Hurston, a key Black feminist writer. They both understand the importance of revolutionizing oneself in order to empower an entire community and change a society. Bambara displays this by stating, “a revolutionary must be capable of, above all, total self-autonomy” (124). She recognizes the faults in not only the groups inflicting discrimination, but also in the inflicted: her own race. She calls out her community and refuses for them to be victimized through explaining that by changing the way their sons and daughters are raised, they can work towards empowering an entire culture to change.

In both pieces, “How It Feels to Be Colored Me” by Zora Neale Hurston and “On the Issue of Roles” by Toni Cade Bambara, both share themes and attributes of being Black feminist writers. In their essays, the topics of race and gender are explored in intersection, with an emphasis put on the journey and important of self-realization and empowerment. Although each piece highlight the aspects of race and gender stronger than the other, they share central ideas that are key to Black feminism literature.